In my personal opinion, I do not like to test, especially in the intelligence
test. Human Intelligence facets many areas of a person's ability, as God grants
a different gift to each human being. In the bible, Paul had mentioned the gifts
of message of wisdom, message of knowledge, healing, prophecy, distinguishing,
speaking different tongues, and interpretation of tongues. How do a person know
which gift (s)he might have? Once upon a time, in a group study, the leader gave
the group member a test, where each one fills a form by answering questions. the
results would tell if you have the gift of teaching, caring, passion, or etc.
Most member laughed after got the result. In the same way, when a school wants
to know if a student is capable of accomplishing school work, it will require
the student do some test. The popularly tests are the academic intelligence
tests such as the SAT/ACT for admission into college, and the GRE/GMAT for
administration of college students into graduate school. Some company designed
test to measure a person's intelligence, such as IQ and the EQ test. These tests
might help recognizing what the students had learned, but not the student's
ability to learn.
The results of the tests might be affected by how many
times a person practices; the more someone practiced and the more familiar (s)he
is with the test, the higher the score (s)he will have. Someone with a PH.D
degree told me that she took the IQ test, and in the beginning, her IQ was
about 120, after took it several times, she got the score of about 140. She said
that if she practiced more, she would have scored higher. so this test means
nothing. Stephen Hawking said about IQ: "People who boast about their IQ are
losers."
People do have intelligence or gift as God granted. A person might
have a gift area and might have another disability area. for example, "Jacob,
who has been diagnosed with mild autism, now 12 years old, mildly autistic and
with an IQ of 170 – higher than Stephen Hawkings and Albert Einstein." Dr.
Hawkings "was small and slow to learn to read" (Journey throught the galaxy) and
has physical disability, He was assumed an extreme high IQ.((it was funny that
Dr. Hawkings hisself said he did not know what his IQ was.) Albert Einstein, who
had difficulty time to learn how to talk. "His elementary school teachers
thought that he was a foolish dreamer, and one teacher had even asked him to
drop out of his class." was assumed that he had extreme high IQ too. Another
factor is "human can be modeled (like plastic), a child who need special
education in an early grade might later be above average, or even
gifted."(Berger K. S. 2009). A person's IQ might change in the life span.
Testing intelligence migh have its limit.
In a way I agree and in a way I disagree. Yes taking a test doesn't determine the students ability to learn; however, taking test can determine where the student academically and intelligently. How can we help our youth if we don't properly teach them? Just as you mentioned about taking a test to see what someone's spiritual gift is, is the same as a child taking an IQ test or an academic test. No one can properly function in their gifting without knowing what it intails, just as a child can not properly learn if they have a learning disability they or their family doesn't know about. Thank you for sharing
ReplyDeleteI placed this loooong response on here and it did not take :-( well to keep it short this time I love the way you put the WORD on here!@!!!!!!!
ReplyDeleteAntowah,i agree with your thoughts regarding the reasoning behind test in schools. And what doesn't make sense is, why require them, when there are loop holes designed to exempt your from them or find ways to enroll you on special provisions. How bout, not require the test in the first place! But, when I joined my church, I took a test to see when area in ministry I should serve in and I was shocked b/c it was not the same as my personal career choice.
ReplyDelete